FMEA – Identifying the Failure Before It Happens

FMEA – Identifying the Failure Before It Happens

A failure discovered in the field is often one that could have been identified during the design phase. FMEA is a systematic engineering tool for identifying potential failure modes, evaluating their effects, and prioritizing risks that require attention—before the failure occurs.

ALD Advanced SolutionsAugust 23, 20266 min read

In this insight you will learn

  • FMEA is a systematic analysis of potential failure modes and their effects—before the failure occurs.
  • Effective analysis requires integrating knowledge from multiple disciplines: development, manufacturing, quality, reliability, and maintenance.
  • The power of FMEA lies in its ability to prioritize risks and allocate resources to the areas with the most impact.
  • The earlier the analysis is performed, the greater the ability to influence the solution at a low cost.
  • FMEA is a living document that is updated throughout the product lifecycle—not a document to be marked as 'done'.

What could go wrong, what would be the impact—and what can be done to prevent it in advance?

In engineering and industrial organizations, a failure discovered by the customer is usually the latest and most expensive stage to find out that something has gone wrong. A product defect, a production line shutdown, a component that does not meet requirements, or a system that does not perform as planned can lead to repair costs, delays, reliability issues, and even safety consequences. One of the central methods for addressing this risk is FMEA – Failure Mode and Effects Analysis, a systematic analysis of potential failure modes and their effects. The main idea is simple: instead of waiting for a failure and investigating it in hindsight, we ask in advance what could go wrong, what the significance would be, and what can be done to reduce the risk. ## What is FMEA? FMEA is a structured tool for identifying and analyzing potential failures in a product, process, or system. There are several types of FMEA – mainly DFMEA for design and PFMEA for process. For the differences between them and the transition from one to the other, read the DFMEA vs. PFMEA Knowledgebase article. During the analysis, we examine, among other things: - What failure modes could occur? - What are the potential effects of each failure? - What are the possible causes of the failure? - What controls are currently in place? - Which risks require high-priority treatment? - What actions can reduce the risk? The goal is not to produce another quality document. The goal is to enable the team to make better engineering decisions before the problem occurs. ## FMEA is not the job of the quality engineer alone One of the common mistakes is to treat FMEA as an activity that belongs to the quality department. Effective analysis usually requires integrating knowledge from several disciplines: engineering, development, manufacturing, quality, reliability, maintenance, and sometimes safety and service as well. Each of these stakeholders brings a different perspective. The development engineer knows the design. Manufacturing personnel know where the process is sensitive. Quality personnel are familiar with anomaly patterns. Reliability engineers look at the system's behavior over time. When this knowledge is combined, the FMEA evolves from a table into a tool for decision-making. ## Not all failures are equal One of the important advantages of FMEA is the ability to prioritize. In a complex system, there can be dozens or even hundreds of possible failure scenarios. It is neither possible nor correct to invest equal effort in all of them. Therefore, the analysis examines the risk associated with each scenario and helps identify where special attention is required. The management question is not just "what can fail?" but also "which failures should we address first?" This transition is especially important when engineering resources, time, and budget are limited. ## A simple example from industry Suppose there is a critical component in a system whose role is to transmit a signal. One of the possible failure modes is the loss of the electrical connection. In FMEA, we do not settle for just writing "loss of connection." We examine the chain: - Failure Mode: Loss of electrical contact - Effect: The system does not receive the required signal - Potential Cause: Improper connection, wear, environmental conditions, or assembly process - Existing Controls: In-process inspections and system testing - Potential Action: Design change, improvement of the assembly process, or addition of appropriate control The real value is not in filling out the rows, but in the discussion they generate. ## When should FMEA be performed? The earlier the analysis is performed, the greater the ability to influence the solution. FMEA can be relevant when developing a new product, changing a design, introducing a new process, changing a manufacturing process, switching to a different supplier, or following new information received from the field. When FMEA is performed only at the end of the project to meet a formal requirement, much of its value has already been lost. A change at an early stage of development might be relatively simple. That same change after the product has already been manufactured, delivered, or implemented by the customer could be significantly more complex and expensive. ## FMEA is a living document Even an excellent FMEA written at the beginning of a project is not meant to remain unchanged. Test results, discovered failures, engineering changes, manufacturing data, and information from the field can change the risk landscape. Therefore, it is correct to treat FMEA as a tool that is updated throughout the lifecycle, rather than a document to be marked as "done." ## The relationship between FMEA and Reliability Engineering and RAMS FMEA is also one of the important tools in the world of reliability. In projects where Reliability, Availability, Maintainability, and Safety (RAMS) analyses are required, a systematic understanding of failure modes and their implications contributes to a broader engineering picture. Read more about ALD's Reliability and RAMS engineering services. The analysis can integrate with other tools and methodologies such as FMECA, Fault Tree Analysis, Reliability Prediction, and other system analyses. The common denominator is moving from a reactive approach to an engineering approach that seeks to understand risk before the failure becomes an incident. ## Good FMEA changes the conversation in the organization The most important question is not whether the organization has an FMEA file. The question is whether the FMEA truly influences decisions. When done correctly, it causes teams to ask questions earlier, expose untested assumptions, identify weaknesses, and allocate resources to areas where they can have a significant impact. And that is exactly the goal: not to document the next failure—but to reduce the probability that it will occur. --- ## Need to perform FMEA, FMECA, or reliability analyses as part of an engineering project? ALD Advanced Solutions provides reliability and RAMS engineering services, system analyses, and professional support for industrial projects. - Reliability and RAMS engineering services - CRE Course — Certified Reliability Engineer - Quality, Standards, and Regulatory services → Talk to us to examine the need and the right solution for your project

“
💬

Insight from Dr. Zigmond Bluvband

“Quality is not created in the final inspection. It is created in the decisions made at the beginning of the project.”

This insight is based on professional knowledge, practical experience and study materials of ALD Advanced Solutions, and inspired by the books and publications of Dr. Zigmond Bluvband.